If Annoyed you are Forcing it

 

How to do Internal Video

The process of learning and development in  Classical Tai Chi is one of being wrong a lot, with corrections you don't immediately understand. Being annoyed is natural, but it also hinders progress.

That is a spot-on assessment of Stephen Hwa’s approach. In his "Classical Tai Chi" (which emphasizes the internal movements of the Small Circle), the learning curve is notoriously steep because it demands a total rewire of how you move your body.

Here is why that "being wrong" phase is so persistent—and how to handle the frustration:

1. The "Internal" vs. "External" Conflict

Most people start by moving their limbs. In Hwa’s lineage (from Young Wabu), the movement must start from the core (the "Dan Tian" and lower back) and radiate out to the limbs. When you get a correction like "don't move your arm," it feels nonsensical because your arm clearly just moved. What the instructor really means is "don't move your arm using your shoulder muscles; move it because your torso rotated."Understanding that distinction takes time for the nervous system to process.

2. The Micro-Correction Trap

Because Classical Tai Chi focuses on "internal squareness" and precise frame alignment, a correction might be about a half-inch shift in your hip or a slight tuck of the tailbone. When you’re told you’re "wrong" for the tenth time on the same move, it’s because you're likely using compensatory movements—muscles jumping in to help. After all, the core isn't strong or coordinated enough yet. [1]

3. Why Annoyance Hinders You

• Physical Tension: Frustration triggers the "fight or flight" response, which tightens the very muscles (shoulders, neck, thighs) that you are trying to relax (Song). You cannot feel internal mechanics through a wall of tense muscle.
• Mental Narrowing: When annoyed, we tend to focus on the result (getting the move right) rather than the process (feeling the connection).

A Better Mindset

Instead of viewing corrections as "being wrong," see them as "data points for your nervous system."

• Accept the Lag: There is always a delay between hearing a correction and your brain actually being able to "find" the muscle required to fix it.
• The "Slow is Fast" Rule: Stephen Hwa often emphasizes slow, deliberate practice. If you find yourself getting annoyed, it’s usually a sign you are trying to "force" the Tai Chi. Back off the intensity, breathe, and let the correction sit in the back of your mind rather than trying to conquer it instantly.

It’s essentially a process of unlearning old habits, which is always more frustrating than learning new ones. 

Yes it’s DIFFICULT

Difficult but here’s a Square & Round Form Intro. 

You are absolutely right. Learning Tai Chi sequences as an adult can feel like learning a complex dance in slow motion while also trying to solve a puzzle with your feet. Unlike "gym" workouts, Tai Chi relies on proprioception—your brain’s ability to know where your limbs are in space without looking at them. 

Here is why it is uniquely challenging and some science-backed strategies to make the memory "stick."

At first, the most difficult aspect of learning Classical Tai Chi is learning to remain still while moving, or more broadly, the mental and physical challenge of developing internal discipline

(moving from the core) rather than relying on external force. 

This difficulty arises because it requires breaking long-held habits of using shoulder and arm muscles and instead engaging deep abdominal and back muscles to drive movement. 

Key Difficulties for Beginners in This System:

• Remaining Still (Stillness in Motion):As noted in Master Hwa's training method, the square form trains the yin/yang principle where movement in one part of the body requires stillness in others. Teaching a student to stay "still" is often harder than instructing them to move.
• 
  
• 
  
• Shifting to Internal Power: Beginners mistakenly try to use external, muscular power (legs and arms) like in other martial arts, which Hwa notes makes them weaker and slower.
• 
  
• 
  
• Understanding the "Square Form":
• Beginners must first master the slow,, precise movements of the "square form" as a blueprint, which acts as a foundational training method to teach internal discipline before progressing to the "round form".
• 
  
• 
  
• Mental Focus: It requires immense mental effort to re-engage a long-neglected nervous system in the torso (core). 
• 
  

The ultimate goal, which is difficult to master, is to integrate the limbs with the core so that internal energy circulates continuously throughout the body during form playing.

The “NOT” moving

 In Classical Tai Chi, the "NOT" moving at the junction of Yin and Yang represents the essential principle of Internal Discipline. The "junction" is a specific area in the torso or joints—such as the waist or upper-quarter body—where the stationary "Yin" (supporting structure) connects with the active "Yang" (moving part). 

This concept can be understood through the following key points:

• Fast Relaxation/Energization: The "not moving" (stillness) at this junction is not passive. It requires rapid relaxation—called Song (松)—to release tension and "energizing" to maintain the structure at the same speed or faster than the moving Yang part.
• 
  
• 
  
• The Goal is Internal Power: When the junction is held still and relaxed, it allows the internal energy (Qi) to compress and flow across that point, creating a "whirlpool" or spring-like effect. This builds immense internal energy in a relaxed body, which can be instantly released.
• 
  
• 
  
• Preventing "Double Weighting": It is the "pivot point" where one side of the body acts as a support, allowing the other to move freely. Your body will not be “double weighted”, aka “double heavy”. Being still at junctions will enable this, and your balance will be maintained. 
• 
  
• 
  
• Distinction Between Yin and Yang: Master Stephen Hwa emphasizes that to distinguish between stillness and motion truly, the Yin part must not move at all, while the Yang moves. As Yang is "hidden" within the stillness of Yin, the contrast between them is heightened, which is key to developing Fajin (the release of power).
• 
  
• 
  
• How it feels: When performed correctly, the practitioner feels a stretching sensation and intense energy flowing across the junction in an otherwise relaxed body. 

In summary, this concept means the junction should not move externally, but must remain dynamically alive and "ready" through instantaneous relaxation and structural integrity. 

Who writes this Blog?

I am with Master Stephen Hwa in Rochester, NY, 2006 and as his senior student I became his first certified teacher. 

 I am the author and driving force behind the Classical Tai Chi Blog. 

The role is multifaceted:

• Author & Instructor: I’m a certified teacher and practitioner of Classical Tai Chi with over 50 years of experience, 23 of those under his tutelage, and I use the blog to share personal insights, practical advice, and detailed technique corrections. 
• 
  
• Lineage Holder: I am fortunate to be the senior student of Dr. Stephen Hwa, who was a direct student of Yang WaBu, a disciple of Wu Chien Chuan, the founder of Wu style Taijiquan. Besides being one of the 1st disciples of Wu Kwong Yu, Classical Tai Chi places me within a direct lineage to the art's origins. 
• 
  
• Preserving Principles: Through the blog, the aim is to focus on preserving and explaining the core principles of Classical Tai Chi, emphasizing internal mechanics, proper alignment, and the circulation of internal energy, often referencing the Tai Chi Classics. 

My training background in Classical Tai Chi is rooted in two key lineages:

• I began studying Tai Chi in 1976, learning both the Yang and Wu styles. 
• 
  
• I am a direct student of Master Stephen Hwa, Ph.D., a leading figure in Classical Tai Chi and a student of Grandmaster Young Wabu. 
• 
  
• I also studied directly with Wu Kwong Yu (Eddie Wu), the great-grandson of Wu Chien Chuan (the founder of Wu style Taijiquan), and was formally recognized as one of his disciples in a ceremony. 

This dual mentorship under Stephen Hwa and Eddie Wu sets a place within a direct and respected lineage of the art. 

Master Stephen Hwa profoundly influenced my practice by introducing me to the underlying principles of "Internal Discipline" that unify Tai Chi's complex. As I said, I was immediately "fascinated" when I began studying with Hwa in 2003. Master Hwa’s analytical and scientific teaching methodology emphasizes core-driven movement rather than external muscle tension, and provides the deep, principled understanding I sought. This mentorship revealed to me "how deep this wonderful art is" and solidified my commitment to preserving and teaching Classical Tai Chi in accordance with these fundamental internal mechanics.

I have applied Master Stephen Hwa's principles of "Internal Discipline" by focusing my training on core-driven movement and eliminating extraneous actions. That training is to ensure all motion originates from the abdomen and back, not from isolated limb actions, and is practiced with a specific "martial intent" (Yi) for each movement. 

It is work to eliminate "localized impulses"—small, unconscious tensions or flicks in the hands, fingers, and feet—that disrupt the flow of internal energy. This includes fully relaxing the toes when lifting a leg, allowing the lower leg to hang naturally, and ensuring movements are crisp and deliberate, especially in the Square Form. With Square Form, one uses pauses at the end of movements to check alignment, relaxation, and mental focus. 

Intuition? Not always…

In Classical Tai Chi (Wu Style Small Frame), one may intuit that all movements are internal whereas in fact they are external, yes that’s “intuition” for you. 

Contrary to this “intuition,” the small circle is counterintuitive. "Counter-Intuition" refers to the practice of Internal Discipline, where external movements are strictly prohibited if they do not originate from the body's core. 

Intuition? Not always video link!

Unlike many forms that focus on flowing arm movements, Classical Tai Chi methodology emphasizes that the limbs should remain relatively still or "engaged" while the torso does the work. 

Counter-Intuitive Principles

• Core Over Limbs: Standard intuition suggests using the shoulder muscles to move the arms; however, the Art teaches that the abdominal and back muscles must move the arms.
• Pulling, Not Pushing: While most people naturally push off the back foot to move forward, Classical Tai Chi requires using the front foot to pull the body forward by engaging the core.
• Stillness as Movement: The "Square Form" training method is designed to teach the student to keep most of the body perfectly still while moving only one specific part—a concept described as harder to master than the movement itself. 

Correct Body Structure

Classical Tai Chi structure is built on the interaction of Yin and Yang within the torso to generate internal power. 

• Internal Junctions: Every movement has a "junction" where a moving part (Yang) works against a stationary part (Yin). In authentic internal movement, this junction must reside in the torsorather than the joints (shoulders, hips, or knees).
• Quadrants of the Body: Movements often utilize only a "quarter" of the body (e.g., the upper-left quadrant) while the other three-quarters act as a solid supporting structure.
• Vertebral Folding: Instead of simple waist turning, the structure uses "folding along the vertebrae," where one side of the back folds in while the other remains stationary to create torque.
• Engaged Arms/Legs: Arms and shoulders must follow the core with minimal independent motion. Moving an arm independently is considered a "weak link" that disrupts the flow of internal energy.

Training Progression

1. Square Form: A "blueprint" for beginners that uses distinct, paused movements to ensure correct internal discipline without taking shortcuts.
2. Round Form: The continuous, fluid version where the pauses are removed, but the internal core-driven mechanics remain identical to the Square Form

Classical Tai Chi is "Non-Intuitive"

 

The psychology of practitioners who study a demanding, disciplined style like Classical Wu Style Tai Chi—which emphasizes Internal Discipline, structural integrity, and martial application—yet challenge their instructors, often stems from a combination of ego, incomplete understanding, and the unique challenges of learning complex, non-intuitive movements. 

 

Tao Te Ching also provides "Non-Intuitive" wisdom in Chapter 2.

When everyone in the world sees beauty,

Then ugly exists.

When everyone sees good,

Then bad exists.

 

Merriam-Webster Dictionary: "Non-intuitive" describes

something not easily understood, learned, or grasped through instinct or common sense, often requiring conscious effort or explanation. It indicates a lack of immediate clarity or self-explanation. Common synonyms include unintuitive, counterintuitive, complex, and subtle

Based on principles of martial arts psychology and the specific context of Classical Tai Chi, here is an analysis of that behavior:

 

1. The "Mid-Journey" Illusion of Knowledge

• False Confidence Phase: Studies of student progression show that after 1–2 years, students often develop a "false sense of understanding". They have mastered basic forms and feel confident, yet lack the depth to realize how much they don't know regarding Internal Discipline.
• Misinterpreting "Softness": Because Classical Tai Chi focuses on relaxation rather than brute strength, beginners may mistakenly believe that any application of force or structural alignment is "incorrect" or "not real Tai Chi," leading them to challenge instructors who are teaching the necessary structural conditioning. 

 

2. Defensiveness and Cognitive Dissonance

• Framework Mismatch: Students who have learned a different, perhaps "softer" or more dance-like version of Tai Chi often become defensive when confronted with a "classical," harder, or more martial approach. Challenging the teacher is a way to defend their previous, less effective training.
• Ego Defense: The process of learning Tai Chi requires relaxing and letting go of the ego. When a student's ego is tied to being "good" or "advanced," they may act out when corrected to protect their self-image, rather than embracing the "empty cup" mentality required for learning. 

 

3. Misalignment of Goals (Martial vs. Wellness)

• The Pursuit of "Magic": Classical Tai Chi emphasizes that internal energy  is generated through strict alignment and physical training, not magic. Students looking for an effortless or purely spiritual practice may argue with a teacher who forces them to do the difficult physical work required for real internal power.
• Disdain for Proper Structure: When a teacher emphasizes the precise mechanics required for martial application, a student focused only on light exercise may feel this is unnecessary or "wrong," which can lead to conflict. 

 

4. Psychological Barriers

• Self-Sabotage: When faced with the difficulty of training their bodies to move in new ways, students may sabotage their progress by arguing with the instructor to avoid the uncomfortable, humbling reality that they are not progressing as fast as they think.
• "Imposter Syndrome": Paradoxically, some students who argue do so because they are insecure and, once they feel the "deeper levels" of training, feel the need to argue to cover up their fear of not being able to achieve it. 

 

Stephen Hwa’s teaching emphasizes that true understanding requires strict adherence to internal principles over the long term. Those who tell teachers they "know better" often possess a "fixed mindset," believing their current, limited understanding is the pinnacle of the art.